By -


Many people believe that a separate property business (meaning a business established prior to marriage) is off limits for the proverbial divorce chopping block.  In most instances, especially those involving a service based business, this could not be further from the truth.


 In a service based industry, where one (or both) spouse(s) work in the business, the community estate can gain an interest pursuant to the case of Pereira.  Pereria, which was decided nearly 100 years ago, carves out a community property interest in a separate property asset.  The analysis is based on the following rationale,


WHERE THE PERSONAL LABOR INVESTED IS THE PRIMARY SOURCE OF GROWTH - A PEREIRA APORTIONMENT ROVIDES A FAIR APPRECIATION AT THE LEGAL RATE OF RETURN TO THE CAPITAL AND ASSIGNS THE REST OF APPRECIATION AS GROWTH FROM LABOR


In real world litigation or mediation perspective, the Pereira interest is generally determined by obtaining two different business valuations, date of marriage and date of separation.  In most cases, the difference between these two values makes up the community property interest.


During the valuation process, a significant amount of work needs to be performed by your lawyers and forensic accounting expert.  You want to make sure that both individuals are readily familiar with your business, your industry and the overall condition of the market.  I myself have handled dozens of cases involving complex business valuations.  Valuing some of these business, some of which grossed yearly figures above $100,000,000.00, required considerable leg work in investigating and understanding that particular industry.


Practical Tips!


* Maintain all relevant financial records for a valuation throughout marriage.  Most banks and financial institutions get rid of records after 7 years.  Said records include, but are not limited to, tax returns, profit and loss statements, and general ledgers.


* Hire an attorney who is experienced in working with valuation experts in assessing businesses from various different industries.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

California Statutory Criteria For Determination of Custody Disputes

By -
Family Code § 3022 provides the court with authority to make an order for the custody of a minor child that seems necessary and proper during the pendency of a proceeding or at any time thereafter.    California family law courts use Family Code § 3040 to establish the order of preference in granting custody in divorce actions.  The first section of this code section provides that “Custody should be granted in the following order of preference according to the best interest of the child as provided in Sections 3011 and 3020.” Parties involved in a custody dispute would be wise to review Family Code §§ 3011 and 3020.  Since these two sections outline the criteria that California judges use to determine custody disputes, parties to such actions should address these factors in their declarations when providing testimony and argument.  Successful litigants spend time addressing facts that directly address these factors.  Spending too much time on facts that do not relate to the a
Read more
By -
Family Law Judgments MAY be Set Aside Due to Fraud!             Civil litigants have the duty and obligation to be transparent with one another. Underhand conduct and trickery cannot and should not be tolerated by the trial court. This extends to the filing of documents with the court and representation made to adverse parties. These requirements are exponentially increased when dealing with a dissolution matter between spouses. The existence of both a confidential and fiduciary relationship requires that parties not only be transparent but also act in accordance with the utmost level of integrity and good faith dealing. When individuals seek to circumvent said requirements, the trials courts have the ability to right the wrong and set aside fraudulent and unjust orders.            Code of Civil Procedure , Section 473 provides in part as follows,  "The court may, upon any terms as may be just, relieve a pa1iy or his or her legal representative from a judgment, dismissal, or
Read more
By -
Image
         Paying too much in Spousal Support? Call us! Modification of a spousal support order is a matter for the exercise of the court’s discretion, based upon a showing of a change of circumstances since the last spousal support order.  In re Marriage of Meegan  (1992) 11 Cal. App. 4 th 156, 161;   In re Marriage of Stephenson (1995) 39 Cal. App. 4 th 71, 76-77. “In determining whether a change of circumstances has occurred, the trial court is required to reconsider the same standards and criteria set forth in . . . now Family Code section 4320 it considered in making the initial long-term order at the time of judgement and any subsequent modification order.”   Marriage of Stephenson (1995) 39 Cal. App. 4 th 71, 77. In other words, in considering a spousal support modification request - … given the predicate of a change of circumstances – the trial court looks at the various factors bearing on spousal support under section 4320.   In re marriage of
Read more