By -




                 THE TEN YEAR "RULE" - NOT REALLY A RULE 
           A number of you have probably come across various "legal" articles discussing a ten year "Rule" in the area of divorce.  I have also read these articles and am astounded at the misinformation contained in them.  First and foremost, marriage duration only impacts spousal support.  You don't get a pot of gold when you hit ten years!  Your property rights don't automatically change nor does your ability to go after your spouse's separate property estate.  
          Furthermore, in regards to spousal support, marriage duration does NOT automatically provide more spousal support.  Discretion is still very much involved. California Family Code section 4336 (b), the section governing the 10 year duration subject, clearly indicates that the trial court has discretion when characterizing the length of a marriage. 
           When a marriage is deemed one of "long duration", a court cannot extinguish jurisdiction at the time of trial unless it makes an explicit finding that the support recipient is 100 % self supporting.  (maintaining jurisdiction means that the court can later {post trial or judgment} render further orders regarding spousal support.) If a party is receiving support, that finding is usually not made.
            Lastly, and probably most importantly, the amount of support ordered is not governed by Family Code Section 4336 but instead by section 4320.  Section 4320 provides more than ten (10) different factors that the court MUST consider when ordering long term spousal support.  Marriage duration is but ONE factor.
            The ten year "rule" is not really a rule but just another factor in the complicated world of spousal support determination and THATS IT!













Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

California Statutory Criteria For Determination of Custody Disputes

By -
Family Code § 3022 provides the court with authority to make an order for the custody of a minor child that seems necessary and proper during the pendency of a proceeding or at any time thereafter.    California family law courts use Family Code § 3040 to establish the order of preference in granting custody in divorce actions.  The first section of this code section provides that “Custody should be granted in the following order of preference according to the best interest of the child as provided in Sections 3011 and 3020.” Parties involved in a custody dispute would be wise to review Family Code §§ 3011 and 3020.  Since these two sections outline the criteria that California judges use to determine custody disputes, parties to such actions should address these factors in their declarations when providing testimony and argument.  Successful litigants spend time addressing facts that directly address these factors.  Spending too much time on facts that do not relate to the a
Read more
By -
Image
         Paying too much in Spousal Support? Call us! Modification of a spousal support order is a matter for the exercise of the court’s discretion, based upon a showing of a change of circumstances since the last spousal support order.  In re Marriage of Meegan  (1992) 11 Cal. App. 4 th 156, 161;   In re Marriage of Stephenson (1995) 39 Cal. App. 4 th 71, 76-77. “In determining whether a change of circumstances has occurred, the trial court is required to reconsider the same standards and criteria set forth in . . . now Family Code section 4320 it considered in making the initial long-term order at the time of judgement and any subsequent modification order.”   Marriage of Stephenson (1995) 39 Cal. App. 4 th 71, 77. In other words, in considering a spousal support modification request - … given the predicate of a change of circumstances – the trial court looks at the various factors bearing on spousal support under section 4320.   In re marriage of
Read more
By -
Image
CIVIL DISCOVERY ACT DOES APPLY TO FAMILY LAW CASES! Often, Family  Law  forget that they are  practicing  civil litigation.  Both statutory and case law have made it abundantly clear, the Civil Discovery Act fully applies to divorce and paternity actions.  Family  Law  attorneys often have no idea how to use the CCP.  You would be shocked to find some Family  Law  attorneys, who call  themselves  experts in the area,  don't even know what a Separate Statement is.  Good luck if you find yourself represented by someone like this.  That being said, lets talk about the formal discovery tools.  One such tool is the INTERROGATORY, AKA a question posed to a party.  Code of Civ. Proc . § 2030.220  provides as follows,  “(a) Each answer in a response to interrogatories shall be as  complete and  straightforwar d as the information reasonably available … (b)  If an interrogatory cannot be answered completely, it shall be answered to the extent possible. (c) If the responding party
Read more